From Robert Raymond

Laurence,

Thank you for your analysis. I am glad someone with analytical skills is watching this line. I’ve often wanted to investigate this line, but have not had the time. It could benefit from extensive old world research with the possibility of putting together an indirect proof of parentage.

Here are a few thoughts on the sources:

  • AGBI is an index to published sources. Rather than believe what Ancestry puts on the screen, we need to access the referenced source and see for ourselves what it has to say and what sources it cites. It appears to be https://www.familysearch.org/search/catalog/45751.
  • Millennium File and the Family Data Collections were collections of unsourced family group sheets acquired by Ancestry. Both are no better sources than what you find on any other unsourced family group sheet.
  • Membership of The Church of … is another compiled source. If I’m not mistaken, Ancestral File was one of her sources. If she doesn’t specify her source for this particular information, or if she specifies Ancestral File, then this information is no more definitive than anything else in Ancestral File.
  • Aunt Effie was apparently an accomplished genealogist, but like others in her generation, I don’t think she specified her sources. But she may be the only source we can find for some of this information. Someone needs to analyze what her probable sources might have been. Can we locate them ourselves? Was she an eyewitness? Did she have contact with an eyewitness? Etc., etc. Standard analyses need to be applied.

Someone needs to hunt down original sources of primary evidence for this information.

Laurence, I hope you will attach your analysis as a document and a source on all the referenced persons. Hopefully this will dissuade others from further messing up this line.

Thanks again for what you are doing,

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Introduction

In order to introduce myself I will give you my relationship to John and Jane Telford. My father was Ivin Lafayette Gee.  He was the son of William Erastus Gee whose mother was Geneva Eleanor Telford the daughter of John Dodds Telford and the granddaughter of John and Jane Telford cousins who married in Ireland and came to Canada and encountered the missionaries of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, went to Kirtland and then to Missouri and then to Nauvoo and then to Utah.  This Blog is created to provide dialog on the family of Jane and John and to help stimulate research.  There is room at the bottom of each post for comments.  We encourage you to use these as a means of communication, questions, thoughts and sources that you have found. We want to correct the errors on Family Search Family Tree with the best information available.
Read more

From Eunice Merrill

Mary. John Dodds Telford is Eliza Victoria Telford’s brother. Eunice Tidwell Merrill 509-264-3484 On Monday, September 3, 2018, 9:51:27 AM PDT, Eunice Merrill < drdadfish@gmail.com > wrote: I received my information from the record of Effie Lenore Wiser and agree with the things you stated. My ancestor was their daughter, Eliza Victoria Telford, who married John McCarthy. He was living with the Anson Call family, who lived across the street from the Telfords. The Call home is still standing. However, the Telford home is no longer there. Eunice Merrill (moved in December 2017  from East Wenatchee WA to Alpine, UT)
Read more